After two renewals, I've finally managed to make it through Kerstin Hall's fantasy adventure
Asunder. This book concerns Karys Eska, a young woman who bound herself to an efferit (demon) in exchange for the power to speak to the dead. She has somewhat unintentionally bound herself to a dying young man, Ferain, who now exists as her shadow. The main plot is trying to separate them without killing either of them.
Please excuse misspellings of names, places, and terms--I listened to the audiobook so I'm guessing here.
Asunder starts from a relatively strong place, and its world-building is very interesting. I think it does a neat thing with the competing sources of magical power, which gives real weight to the opposing schools of magic. The OG magical powers-that-be, the bhatuma, have been overthrown in Karys' home country, and folks like Karys can now compact with and draw power from the new kids on the block, the efferete. You all know I don't care much for hand-holding in SFF, and Hall does make you learn as you go with her complex world, but I think it works and I never felt truly lost or unable to understand the plot. There are lots of fun fantasy things, like the giant hand elevators, and the dimension-warping spiders, that are simply never explained, and I enjoy that. What's fantasy if everything is explained? That's just science!
However, there are a lot of other things that just fell flat for me.
I'm all for unlikeable or complicated protagonists, but Karys wore on me after 20 hours. Her character makes
sense, in that someone who's been on her own virtually her whole life likely
would be inclined to Karys' attitudes, but it was just exhausting after a while, partly because she doesn't change at all throughout the story. She warms up to Ferain eventually, but her relationships with Wynola and Haeki are pretty much the same at the end as at the start, her views on the world and herself don't change, her opinions of past events remain the same...she's almost completely static. Throughout the novel she remains withdrawn, touchy, independent to the point of being irritating, unwilling to help others and baffled by anyone who feels otherwise, and eager to rip into anyone who sets off her temper.
Ferain is regrettably flat. It's obvious he exists solely for Karys to love him; and how could she not? He's infinitely patient, kind, witty, in touch with his feelings and open about them, adept at reading people so Karys never has to actually explain how she's feeling, worldly, and wholly lacking in class prejudice despite being raised in wealth. Ferain never once starts a fight with Karys or even snaps back when she loses her temper with him, which is pretty astounding given that he's trapped in her mind for weeks and it's alleged this situation causes him pain, or at least discomfort. Like Karys, Ferain remains static throughout the novel. Despite the fact that a minor fuss is made about Karys discovering that Ferain is actually a very slick liar, nothing ever comes of this between them; Karys never truly suspects Ferain might be lying to her about something (and he never does).
I do think Hall does something interesting with Haeki and Karys' dynamic, both being from a small town and then thrust out into the world. Haeki's insecurities make perfect sense, particularly as she and Karys now find themselves on opposing sides of the bhatuma/efferete divide. They have a really crunchy interplay of obviously loving each other, and knowing each other as only two people who grew up together can, but having that relationship soured by adult-life events like jealousy, bitterness, and mistrust. However, some kind of resolution or growth in this relationship would have been nice to see. As noted, they finish about where they started.
These characters are meant to be in their late 20s, but they are immature for their age, and the story often comes off with a YA patina, which I didn't care for. Their behavior and dialogue often feels younger than their stated ages.
A story like this pretty much lives and dies off the dynamic of its main duo, and I unfortunately just did not find Karys and Ferain's relationship compelling. It just didn't move me at all, perhaps partly because Karys seems so genuinely pissed and uncomfortable at having Ferain around most of the time, which results in a lot of his cringing about existing where he's not wanted, and it takes a long time for this dynamic to shift at all. Because the platonic element never took off for me, the romance felt trite. At least if they had ended without that, it could have been an interesting queerplatonic partners angle or something, but of course they start crushing. Beyond me how Ferain is willing to give his life for Karys after what the last few weeks have entailed. It also doesn't even
begin to emerge until the novel is at its 80% mark, and it changes basically nothing about the plot, which makes it feel like even more of a last-minute add-on.
There are side plots that go nowhere (
what was the deal with Rasko's package?) and in retrospect feel like bloating in an already long novel.
I will credit Hall for not overplaying her hand with Sebaster. It would have been easy for her to push him more into the story, resulting in villain decay, but by keeping him a constant threat on the edges who we rarely
actually encounter, she keeps him scary. His relationship with Karys is interesting too; the efferete come off suitably inhuman and Sebaster seems almost incapable of understanding human feelings or motivations. Despite the monstrous end he intends for Karys, he seems to genuinely respect and care for her.
The ending did not land for everyone, but I didn't mind it. It felt pretty true to the vibes of this universe and I don't mind a conclusion that implies the protagonist immediately setting off on another adventure. There are rumors Hall intends a sequel; I don't care and I won't be reading it. This was more than enough for me.